PDA

View Full Version : Would you want an upside down Christmas tree?


ladymelissa
10-15-2006, 09:58 PM
What is your opinion of this trend?

http://www.usatoday.com/life/lifestyle/2005-11-07-christmas-trees_x.htm

Fake trees turn Christmas on its head
By Craig Wilson, USA TODAY
Has your holiday imbibing gotten out of control so soon?

Inverted evergreen: Novelties, space savers or something more sinister?
www.ChristmasTreeForMe.com

Maybe that Christmas tree you saw really is upside down. Upside-down trees are, well, turning the upcoming holiday on its head.

Hammacher Schlemmer can't even keep its $599.95 pre-lit model in stock. It's already sold out.

"We increased the amount we ordered from last year, but ended up selling all of them already," says Joe Jamrosz of Hammacher Schlemmer.

Not to be left behind, Target has three such upside-down trees ($299.99-$499.99) on its website, touting their best attribute: "Leaves more room on the floor for gifts!"

Similar trees are also available at ChristmasTreeForMe.com in the 5-to-7½-foot range ($280-$504).

The artificial trees are hung from the wall or ceiling, or come with a weighted base to provide extra stability to prevent tipping and leaning.

Sheryl Karas, author of The Solstice Evergreen: The History, Folklore and Origins of the Christmas Tree, isn't quite sure what's going on with the resurgence of upside-down trees, a 12th-century tradition in Central Europe.

"But it's the question I get more often than any other on my website," says the Santa Cruz, Calif., author (sherylkaras.com).

Karas believes it's purely a decorative thing this time around, a way to better display ornaments so they don't get lost in the foliage. She doesn't want to put a damper on the holidays, but she suspects "there's something sinister, almost bad, about it."

Because the shape of the tree is symbolic (pointing to heaven), "if they thought about it, they wouldn't turn it upside down," she says.

But enough playing Scrooge. It's the holiday season.

"Many of the people have been using them as their second tree. A novelty," Jamrosz says. "They also find the bigger gifts don't fit under a traditional tree."

Hanging a tree from the ceiling also ensures a smaller footprint for less-spacious areas. You can put it between two closely placed chairs, for instance.

But not everyone is head over heels about the trend. Tree Classics Inc. of Lake Barrington, Ill., claims to be the top seller of artificial Christmas trees on the Internet — up 30% this year alone — but not a one of them is upside down.

"That tree makes no sense to me whatsoever," says Tree Classics president Leon Gamze, who sells 59 styles of upright trees. "I just look at them and laugh." But would he ever join the upside-down trend?

"Never. Wouldn't even consider it."

Probably a good thing. He'll never have to ponder whether to put a star at the top, or bottom, of such a thing.

ladymelissa
10-15-2006, 10:02 PM
Here's a pic:

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a64/ladymelissa/Misc/upsidedowntree.jpg

ladymelissa
10-15-2006, 10:09 PM
I saw this in a store today and I thought it was a joke by the person who sets up the displays, come to find out it is some sort of trend.

I don't want one, I think they look very awkward and just plain strange. I would be more apt to buy a purple tree (with purple branches) or the lighted palm trees before this. But that's just me.

MOB Karen
10-15-2006, 10:14 PM
Never! I don't like it at all! :snide:

WebLady
10-15-2006, 11:20 PM
I saw this in a store today and I thought it was a joke by the person who sets up the displays, come to find out it is some sort of trend.

I don't want one, I think they look very awkward and just plain strange. I would be more apt to buy a purple tree (with purple branches) or the lighted palm trees before this. But that's just me.
ITA ... I haven't seen these yet but I think they are weird looking. They even have one that hangs upside down from the ceiling :bbrolleyes:

http://www.christmastreeforme.com/images/detail_161775cc_RL05_35.jpg

I would never buy one of these atrocities ... If I didn't have the space for a tree, I'd get a small little one or just not have one.

ladymelissa
10-16-2006, 12:05 AM
ITA ... I haven't seen these yet but I think they are weird looking. They even have one that hangs upside down from the ceiling :bbrolleyes:


I read about the kind that hang, but I had no idea what it would look like! Thanks for the pic!

ITA about the space issue!

FutureBride
10-16-2006, 05:20 AM
For a tree,thats too much.

SerendipityCrafts
10-16-2006, 06:56 AM
I could probably use one because we don't have the space but nah ...... I wouldn't go for it.

I am a bit of a tree snob ... it has to be a real tree. Even if I could figure out how to hang it upside down ... I would constantly be picking up needles! LOL

hummingbird521
10-16-2006, 08:20 AM
Nope that is not something I would consider, even with a space issue.

Jacklynn
10-16-2006, 08:25 AM
I do believe that is the ugliest thing I have ever saw. It doesn't even look like a Christmas tree. I would be laughing pretty hard if I walked into someone's house and saw that lol

katieandalex
10-16-2006, 09:02 AM
Thats not really what I was thinking....but my mom has this tree thats called and upside down Christmas tree...but it totally doesn't look like that. She just has hers as a 2nd tree...and thats all I would do with it. But the one you posted, I would never do it.

BriansBride07
10-16-2006, 10:43 AM
LOL ok too funny my FH has told me stories before that his grandmother was such a pack rat that she hung her tree from the ceiling since there was no other place to put it. And actually left it up all year long. The only way I would buy one of these trees is if they come down big time in there price. I would also only use it as a second tree maybe on the front porch for a decorative piece and something for people to talk about.

Kacie_bride
10-16-2006, 11:17 AM
No, I think it's ugly.

Jenn060306
10-16-2006, 11:34 AM
One word....


YUCK!

rainbowtreat
10-16-2006, 12:49 PM
nope sorry not in my house, noep not happening, who the hell came up with that idea any way

ladymelissa
10-16-2006, 01:47 PM
Thats not really what I was thinking....but my mom has this tree thats called and upside down Christmas tree...but it totally doesn't look like that. She just has hers as a 2nd tree...and thats all I would do with it. But the one you posted, I would never do it.
I am interested to see what hers looks like, the pic I posted was with the USA Today article that I had found. Even the one in the store was literally a tree standing on it's top. Maybe they look different with ornaments on or something.

ladymelissa
10-16-2006, 01:54 PM
who the hell came up with that idea any way

According to the article it was previously done in the 12th century: Sheryl Karas, author of The Solstice Evergreen: The History, Folklore and Origins of the Christmas Tree, isn't quite sure what's going on with the resurgence of upside-down trees, a 12th-century tradition in Central Europe.

Karas believes it's purely a decorative thing this time around, a way to better display ornaments so they don't get lost in the foliage. She doesn't want to put a damper on the holidays, but she suspects "there's something sinister, almost bad, about it."

70707Bride
10-16-2006, 04:44 PM
No, it looks like a tornado! LOL, it already looks like one went through our house, we don't need another one!

vicky_vicky
10-16-2008, 06:25 PM
Ok now, why would I want an unside down tree?? no way. If I wanted to save space I would get a smaller upright tree.

katrina7875
10-16-2008, 06:35 PM
No way - too weird. I like having an elegant tree and to me that is not elegant!

amisteratwisterandme
10-16-2008, 06:42 PM
Somethings should just be kept sacred ya know?